Solving the Suarez Problem

This article is NOT about handshakes, racism, tribalism or morality in football. I’ll leave the meaty topics like them to my esteemed colleagues here at Paisley Gates. Or people like John Barnes, far better qualified and positioned to speak on such issues than I.

Nor is it about selling Suarez – an idea I find laughable at present, but one that could nevertheless still become reality if controversy continues to follow Luis and his ultra-competitive consequentialist on-field demeanor. Instead, this article is about embedding Luis in a winning team, finding the balance of personnel and tactics that will see both the club and player flourish – a combination likely to minimise bad news days at LFC in future. Indeed, with two cup fixtures on the horizon (including our first final appearance since the Nightmare of Athens in 2007) the opportunity is there to begin to forge an identity of our own choosing. The light of victory always reflects well.

So what do we do to win these two cup games? How do we get some positive press for our maligned forward duo, Luis Suarez and Andy Carroll? Can they actually play together? What does that mean for the tactical formation and shape of the team? Can we maintain our comparative success with 4-3-3 and still field both players?

We Must Go After Our Opponents
Andy Carroll and Luis Suarez must start together, against both Brighton and Cardiff. Individually they have features that make them extremely difficult to play, and with Carroll’s link play finally in evidence, the likelihood of a successful partnership (against theoretically weaker opposition) seems higher now. With Brighton offering a reasonable challenge earlier in our Carling Cup journey, our FA Cup clash against them at Anfield provides the perfect opportunity for us to work on the Suarez-Carroll combination, while also hopefully clearing the logjam in front of goal that’s been keeping the scorekeepers untroubled so far this season. We need purpose, controlled aggression, confidence and meaningful dominance to succeed, and we need them right from the first whistle.

Shape is Less Important Than Movement
Whether or not we play a 4-3-3 variant or a 4-4-2, movement is the key to success. When we move well, we play well. In our recent 2-1 loss to Manchester United, the sight of midfielders raising their arms in frustration at the lack of forward passing options was all too regular. The movement ahead was too pedestrian, too one-dimensional. Suarez looked to get in behind, but the early ball was never released, and he never managed to find space anywhere. Andy Carroll changes that dynamic. While his movement isn’t top level (yet), he draws defenders to aerial contests they can’t win, or forces them to guess a position where they might be able to intercept his flick-ons. Provided players are running the channels in anticipation (a la Kuyt versus United at Anfield in the FA Cup) this can create a lot of space for clever, busy players, like Bellamy, Suarez and Kuyt to exploit.

For me it’s a foregone conclusion that Craig Bellamy has to start, particularly against former club Cardiff at Wembley. He not only adds a vital blend of pace, experience and desire, he also brings far more avenues to goal than any other player we have. Fast breaks, poachers’ goals, long-range potshots – Bellamy scores them all. He’s also the best direct freekick taker at the club bar none. His delivery from corners is consistently good, and he’s intelligent enough to swap positions with Suarez seamlessly when the Uruguayan takes up a wide position. More than most, Bellamy is desperate to win something – and now possesses the maturity to see it done right. Maybe too Luis Suarez could learn something from Bellamy on taming his own “inner chimp”.

Don’t Underplay Midfield Control
While I think we will probably see a 4-4-2 for long stretches in both games, either by design or by the default shape that Suarez’ presence seems to give to the forward line any time he plays with Andy Carroll, I think serious thought should be given to securing and dominating the midfield.

Even the thought of a partnership of Adam and Gerrard terrifies me, with neither suited to protecting their defenders as a primary role. Spearing and Adam give the deeper midfield a good range of passing, provide reasonable balls forward, and should have the ability to control their opposition at this level.

That combination would also set Gerrard free to occupy an attacking midfield role. This would mean Suarez starting from a nominally wide right position (his best in my opinion), but his natural movement inside towards goals would be counter-balanced nicely by Gerrard’s tendency to drift to the right flank, looking to whip in a cross or play Johnson in behind the opposition fullback.

Essentially their movement converts a 4-3-3 or 4-2-3-1 into a 4-4-2 in attack, as represented by the movement arrows on the formation diagram.

Jordan Henderson and Dirk Kuyt may need to content themselves with substitute roles in both matches, as might Stewart Downing, who has cut an increasingly forlorn figure during his difficult first year at Liverpool. Hopefully, by the time any of them see any action, both matches have already been well and truly won.

-Grubb-

Give us a Like on Twitter, Follow us on Facebook. Go against the grain!

  • Ted

    Spearing is NOT good enough as clearly seen in the MU game – he is simply not up to top level football – maybe suited to a lower level EPL team or a Championship team but is NOT LFC material .. If KD cannot see this then im sorry but he is also not up to LFC Management standard.. 

  • Kingkenny66

    spearing had a bad game ..that s it 2 me…i like him and his hunger….ynwa

  • CSD

    I get tingly when people use the word “consequentialist.”

  • Grubb

    That’s knee-jerkism surely? Yes his error against United was poor, and he isn’t top class. But he is good enough now to plug gaps against most teams and has potential to develop even further. If Lucas was fit, Spearing wouldn’t be starting matches he isn’t ready for. Let him mature. He has LFC in his blood and on song he adds to rather than detracts from play. Winning a cup could trigger another quantum leap in his growth like the one we have seen this year. Dalglish knows what Jay’s level is better than we do.

  • Grubb

    It was either that or “Machiavellian”!

  • NJRedsFan

    Reina
    Kelly, Skrtel, Agger, Enrique
    Johnson, Maxi
    Gerrard
    Suarez, Bellamy
    Carroll

  • Mike

    And to be fair, Jay is replacing the best CDM in the League at the moment. It’s hard for him to match the composure, distribution and positional sense of Lucas, but if the option is Charlie Adam, by comparison we have a Patrick Viera on our hands. (Although I do share Ted’s frustration with Jay’s inconsistencies.)

  • picturing Spearing as a huge black man made me giggle.
    that’s not racist, is it? picturing a little White man 4 feet taller & 200 pounds heavier and Black?

    it’s hard to tell these days.